|
Yesterday, Zillow and Realtor.com announced something that has never happened in the thirty-year history of online real estate.
The two largest home search platforms in the country, longtime competitors, are joining forces. Why?
Starting this summer, Zillow Preview listings will appear on Realtor.com as Realtor.com Preview. No special login. No brokerage membership required.
Any buyer using either platform will see the same pre-market homes at the same time. Together, the two portals reach roughly three-quarters of online home shoppers in America.
This is breaking news. It is also a direct response to a much bigger story that started in February, and it matters for every seller and buyer in the Lakes Region.
The Backstory: What Compass and Rocket Built in February
In late February, Compass closed its acquisition of Anywhere Real Estate, which brought Coldwell Banker, Century 21, Corcoran, and Sotheby's International Realty under its roof. That made Compass the largest residential brokerage in the world.
Days later, Compass announced a three-year alliance with Rocket Companies, which owns Redfin and Rocket Mortgage.
Under that deal, up to 500,000 Compass listings, including "Coming Soon" properties and "Private Exclusives," flow first to Redfin. They do not appear on Zillow or Realtor.com during that window. And when they do appear on Redfin, key consumer information is stripped out. No days on market.
No price history. All buyer inquiries route directly to Compass agents. Rocket Mortgage gets preferred placement for those buyers.
In plain English, Compass and Rocket built a walled garden. Compass controls the listings. Rocket controls the financing. Redfin is the storefront. Outside buyers, outside agents, and the consumer data that helps both sides negotiate fairly are kept at arm's length.
Yesterday's Announcement Was the Counter-Move
Zillow and Realtor.com answered with the opposite philosophy.
Their alliance does three things.
First, it puts pre-market listings in front of every buyer on either platform, regardless of which brokerage that buyer is working with.
Second, it includes more than sixty participating brokerages, among them Keller Williams, RE/MAX, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, HomeServices of America, Engel & Völkers, Leading Real Estate Companies of the World, and eXp-affiliated Side.
Third, it costs sellers nothing, and it does not require buyers to sign in or register with any specific company to see the homes.
Two camps are now visible to anyone willing to look.
The restricted camp. Compass, Rocket, and Redfin. Listings curated, exposure limited, consumer data hidden, leads captured inside the system.
The open camp. Zillow, Realtor.com, and a coalition of independent, franchise, and brokerages. Listings visible to everyone, full consumer data displayed, buyers free to choose their own agent.
The Truth Through the Smoke and Mirrors
Both sides will spin this with words like choice, transparency, innovation, and consumer benefit. Read the press releases carefully and you will find all four words on both sides. So let me tell you what is actually true.
Truth one. When a listing is shown to fewer buyers, fewer buyers compete for it. Less competition lowers the final sale price. This is not opinion. It is how auctions work, and a real estate sale is a slow-motion auction. A seller who limits exposure is, on average, leaving money on the table.
Truth two. When days on market and price history are hidden, the buyer loses information and the seller loses accountability. Both sides need that data. A seller sitting at the wrong price for ninety days needs to know so they can adjust. A buyer being asked to overpay needs to know so they can negotiate. Hiding it benefits the brokerage, not the consumer.
Truth three. The large publicly traded brokerages, Compass and Rocket included, are not building these systems out of affection for the consumer. They are building them to capture leads, double-end transactions, and route buyers into their own mortgage and title services. That is a legitimate business model. It is not a fiduciary one, and it should be named honestly.
Truth four. Zillow and Realtor.com are not nonprofits either. They have commercial reasons for taking the open position. The difference is that the open position happens to align with what is actually best for most sellers most of the time, which is maximum exposure from day one.
Why This Matters Here in the Lakes Region
Waterfront and second-home markets run on a different rhythm than most of the country. Buyers compress into a narrow summer window. Many of those buyers are out of state, planning trips around showings, building a short list before they ever arrive. If your home is sitting in a private network during the weeks those buyers are searching, you are invisible to them at the exact moment they are most motivated.
That is not a small problem. On a Lake Winnipesaukee property, the difference between full exposure and limited exposure can be tens of thousands of dollars, and on the upper end it can be hundreds of thousands. I have seen it. The seller who insists on the widest possible audience almost always nets more than the seller who agrees to be hidden.
What I Tell My Clients
When a seller hires me, my obligation is to that seller's outcome, not to my brokerage's lead pipeline. That means I push for the broadest exposure on day one, full data displayed, every qualified buyer competing. When a buyer hires me, my obligation is to protect them from overpaying, which means I want every comparable, every price history, and every day-on-market figure on the table.
If a system hides those things from my clients, I will say so out loud. That is the job.
If You Want to Do Something About This
I have been working on this issue for months. If you want to understand the policy fight, see which states have already acted to ban or restrict private listing networks, and find out how to push for fair and transparent listing rules here in New Hampshire, please visit equalaccesslistings.info. The site explains the problem in plain language and shows you how to make your voice heard with the people who write the rules.
The portal wars will keep moving. The headlines will keep getting noisier. My job is to cut through the smoke and tell you what is actually happening, so you can make decisions with clear eyes.
If you have questions about how any of this affects your own home, your sale, or your search, call me directly. That is what I am here for.
|
